00:00
00:00
BlazingDragon

126 Audio Reviews w/ Response

All 186 Reviews

Upon first listening, the piece sounded a bit rough for my tastes. The melodic material doesn't particularly stick in my mind after the last note fades, and the overall texture holds a certain cacophonous feel. However, music does not exist in a vacuum for the mere sake of beauty, and it is only fair to scrutinize a piece based on context and how successfully it meets a compositional goal. When reading the story and examining the artwork that the music is inspired by, a great deal of imagery comes flooding to mind, creating a sensible framework that proves the piece artistically competent.

Several musical devices work cleverly with the story that you provide. For example, the sixteenth note string ostinato so prevalent throughout the piece provides a terrible sense of anxiety. It could be representative of how the people feel under their tyrannical king; overworked, frantic, fearful, scrambling to get along. Yet the strings are subdued beneath the brass as if to show how the voice of the people has been silenced. Their fear and disdain only exist as a tense underlying feeling. No one in the kingdom dares to openly speak against the king.

Similarly, the timpani sounds wearily every two beats as if a drum of war. The army marches on in fear and desperation, starved and on edge. The sounding of the male chant is the voices of slaves shouting their "heave, hoe" under the searing brutality of the sun.

The trumpet dissonances toward the beginning usher in the harshness of a new rule, and the diminished chord outlined by the timpani is indicative of the king's maddened instability. The unexpected, shifting modulations are indicative of the ruler's bipolar violence.

At 1:20 though, the tone changes completely. Gone are the wearied chants of slaves and the anxious, hushed whispers of the populace. No longer do the discordant diminished harmonies sound. In their place is new music: Heroic. Brave. Majestic. This is how the king views himself. He is a powerful and noble ruler! He took this weak, pathetic country and shaped it into a glorious kingdom for the world to marvel at! No foe would dare raise their sword against him. He is the protector of the people, a ruler just and divine, the reincarnation of God guiding these poor wretches! And yet even in this triumphant music, slight tensions plague the soundscape in the form of suspensions. These show how polluted the king's self-deception truly is. And then the voices of slaves and armies carry on.

Were these illustrations thought of when composing, meticulously crafted in to paint a sadistic and insidious picture? Perhaps not on a conscious level. If nothing else, however, they show that you have a great intuition as a musical story-teller. You keenly pick the tools that effectively convey your ideas. Your piece is very successful in this sense.

That is not to say that the composition is flawless. Balance could be better executed in my opinion. There were certain instances in which the horn could have been brought out a bit more to make the melody cut through the clutter, or in which the strings could have made themselves more apparent. A few transitions, such as the one around :54, could have been more captivating through the use of a sforzando/piano quickly rising with a pronounced crescendo. The ending seemed unprepared, perhaps tacked on without quite enough consideration. Extending the last few bars by elongating their rhythmic values may have led to a stronger cadence and sense of finality.

That said, I am still impressed with the piece. My criticisms are certainly picky, and your musical intuition shows strong in this work. Your textual storytelling ability is also a wonderful companion to your composition skills.

I enjoyed this and will be listening for more from you!

Bosa responds:

I couldn't of said it better myself. Maybe you ought to write the stories from now on.

I'm trying to improve my musical skill as I go on, so hopefully I'll have something worth presenting next time. But I'm really nothing, and there are better composers out there than I.

Etheral and beautiful

You have crafted a beautiful rendition of a beloved tune. Thank you for pouring effort into this and sharing it with the audio portal. :)

First off, the piece is nearly identical to the source material in terms of harmony. That said, I love how you have managed to provide freshness within that framework! The dream-like choral atmosphere is a nice departure from the myriad of piano renditions that are always popping up.

The harp arpeggios provide a sweet, dolce kind of backdrop to the piece. The melody though...is that just a piano doubling the vocal lead? Or is it also being doubled with a unison harp line? It is difficult to tell due to the reverb, but I rather like the bell-like timbre. Whatever the case, you choice in orchestration is simple but effective.

My favorite part of the piece is the a cappella section starting at 2:22. The chord at 2:29 was particularly colorful. I wish it would have held longer!

Lovely vocal performance, sweet lyrics, a deeply reverbed sound scape (which I am a sucker for), lovely counter melodies and smooth voice leading...Very nice. Still, there were a few things that I think could have made it even better.

-You have a lovely, well developed ending. I would have loved to hear an introduction with the same amount of effort poured in. The four bar harp intro just didn't do it for me. Maybe you could have developed an instrumental beginning that would deviate a little more from the source in terms of harmony? Or perhaps you could have started off a capella for a sort of full-circle approach in relation to the end. While you don't NEED an introduction, the more that I listen to this piece, the more it seems like should be there.
-More creative phrase shaping in regard to tempo! Slight ritards at the end of phrases, pauses in the music to let it breath...For example, the cadence at 1:12. I really wanted that to linger! Especially with the lyrics, "The sun has said goodnight." There is a huge opportunity for word painting there! As if the day is coming to an end, you could let the phrase slow down and that chord ring out for a little bit, you know? And the chord at 2:29 has some tension in it that is different from the rest of the piece. I want a fermata there so bad!!! lol :)
-This is really nit-picky, but I'm having to hunt for details because your piece is so good. The breath at 2:08 was a little fast and noticeable. It might be better to relax and breath for a few beats beforehand as to not draw attention to itself. Then again, that might just be choir mode kicking in for me. I'm probably over-analyzing.
-Where this room has the most room to grow is dynamically. For such a dreamy atmosphere, it is fairly stagnant in terms of dynamics. More contrast between phrases and sections would help make the piece more organic and interesting. A decrescendo on the last chord of the piece would have also added a little more emotional power, I think.

Well, sorry for rambling. It's really late and I'm not totally coherent or awake! All in all, lovely work, and I look forward to more from you in the future. ^_^

Originality
harmony
melody
performance
mastering/mixing
orchestration

VGSongbird responds:

Holy Shit. I feel like I just got sent back to school by a music teacher :D

No, really, I appreciate this feedback; clearly you know a thing or two about music. As for your feedback, I'd like to respond in part with agreeing with you. When I posted this, I was literally taking a break from a different project, and I probably could've put more work into dynamics, levels, and phrasing. If I knew it was going to receive the attention it did, I certainly would have! I left the breath in at 2:08 on purpose, but now listening to it over, I probably should've taken it out.

As for the instruments, I wouldn't change them. I kept them simple, because I wanted them to not become the MAIN focus of the song. The piano in the background is the melody. The Harp is the bass line. And the vocal lines are all simplistic to emulate the idea of a mother--someone who could be anyone's mother--singing to her sleeping child. I did cave at the end and get some more detailed chords, but the main theme of the song was simplicity... a lullaby a mother thinks up on the spot to calm her daughter.

But thank you for your high score regardless of my technical failings. I appreciate the support, and this well thought review! :D

Nice and chill

Reminds of Place to Be by Hiromi at some points. Not as crazy technical of course, but moody all the same. And that is a huge compliment.

There are just a few spots that I felt detracted from the mood, verging a bit too much to the funky side. Nice improv anyway!

Check Hiromi out and tell me this doesn't sound a LITTLE similar:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LKuEJB KRW4M

Then again, maybe it doesn't. Who knows? :)

MrMusicalLion responds:

It's definitely got a similar vibe at some points. Hiromi goes for a more cold and cool approach more often, and when it is moody, it is not as moody as this - but the mood is very similar. I had never heard of her before now actually. How bizarre.

Anywho thankyou!

Fun, repetitive

When the beginning notes chimed in, the image of an alarm ringing came to mind. I can see a character waking up and jumping out of bed with this big, silly grin as he prepares for the day ahead. Life is bright and whimsical like much of the Pokemon universe. Life is a party!

For the description that you provided, the music fits quite well and gets that general party feel across. I love how you come in with a single ringing tone, introduce a flamboyant melodic line, gradually bring in percussion, and build the texture at the beginning. That approach creates a very catchy feel and demand for listener attention. The composition following is catchy and fun.

There are some notable weak points, however. The "alarm" sound at the beginning continues through the entire piece and becomes a bit grating on my ears after a while. Additionally, the same phrase is repeated over and over for around two minutes, and that can lose the interest of your audience.

First, try bringing the melody line up dynamically to set it apart in the mix. Pull the other elements down some. Primarily around :48. This will make the sound a little less muddy. Also, try introducing some contrasting material to change things up. Different harmonies, varied percussive lines, lose the alarm sound for a bit, etc. I liked how you dropped many instruments around 2:36 (though it was a bit sudden). Do more things like that to get away from that same sound that sustains through the piece.

Good job on this; it is catchy and very fun. The syncopated rhythms draw me in. Find ways to create more contrast though, and use more types of musical texture. Keep it up!

Croire responds:

Holy crap tis gave me the biggest smile!!!! Definitely taking your tips to heart!!

Fierce! :o

Melody, harmony, rhythm: You have a great sense of chord progression. The harmonic structure that you use is very fitting to the scene that you've presented, and I can imagine the image that you have portrayed. My main issue is that in this piece, there isn't a very developed sense of melody. You have a lot of cool sounds mingling together, but it's difficult to pick out a hummable melody that the listener will be whistling long after playing the game. That is important for a scene like this, I believe. The french horn kind of has it, but it's not clear.

Mixing/Mastering: One way you can bring that melody is by bringing up the volume of that horn. Also, by panning different instruments to different speakers, you can make them sound distinctive and a bit less muddy (I can't really tell if you panned, I'm on a laptop).

Phrasing, dynamics, etc.: This is a pretty dynamic piece with all of the crescendos and decrescendos. It sounds pretty organic in that sense. Balance is a slight issue though.I would have liked to hear a tad more of the piano at 1:11ish, but that is picky.

Other: This is an emotionally effective piece. It is varied and dynamic in its volume and texture. I can clearly imagine the scene that you describe, and with some sound effects, this would be really cool. The piano at the beginning was a nice touch. However, the ending piano notes sounded slightly off to me for some reason...

Overall, very nice. This being your first "classical" attempt, it turned out quite successful. It could be refined in a few ways, but great job. Keep 'em coming!

BlueScreenRemix responds:

I understand what you mean about the melody, and I agree with you. Listen again, I edited the audio file on newgrounds, the song is cleaner and I turned up the horn sound.
Sorry for your laptop, I panned :P
Thank you for your helpfull review ! Keep following and helping us !

Cool sound, but unfocused

This gives me the image of a man charging through the battle field in slow motion. A bullet rips through his soldier and his face contorts in agony. Yet he presses forward, blood seeping from his wound. Another bullet glances across his thigh, tearing through his clothing and opening a new wound, He knows that he will die, but a certain sense of pride fills his soul. As one last bullet pierces his chest, he falls to his knees...the world is spinning, crashing, blackening...In his last moments, he remembers his wife and son. The love that he feels for them is almost tangible. He is content dying to protect them, and he thanks God for freedom. A single warm tear rolls down his cheek as his final breath is surrendered on the battlefield. The man will be forever remembered as a hero, but more importantly, as a loving father and husband.

Musically, I like a lot of what is going on. The percussive riff you have going on provides for a unique military flare despite the otherwise subdued music. The piano has its occasional dissonance, highlighting the struggle that a soldier faces. Yet the chord progression and orchestration paint a feeling of hopefulness.

You have a nice orchestral color going, but this piece only really amounts to background music. This is because there isn't a clear, focused sense of melodic development. For the most part, your melody line seems to go to the trumpet. However, it mostly lives in whole notes that are part of the chord. Make it a bit more rhythmically active and add some nonharmonic tones. Make a clear climax in the melody and build up before it. Increase the tension toward the end and make your music gripping! This is war, struggle, heartache! You could build up with a huge crescendo, thicken the texture, use more dissonant harmonies, speed up the tempo, use a more lively rhythm, or any number of things to create more of a climax.

In other words, this piece suffers most from stagnancy. It is pleasant but not entirely memorable. The way you make a piece memorable is often through tension and relief, and through a thoughtful melody. You have good compositional instincts already- I can tell through your harmonies. But develop it- study some music theory, and analyze great music. Think, "What is it that makes this such a successful piece? Why do I like it so much? How can I emulate it?"

You have a great start. Continue moving forward musically, and don't stop composing. :)

All the best,
BlazingDragon

Rampant responds:

Hello,
Well to be complimented even slightly by such a talented composer is wonderful indeed!

Originally, this was to be the background music for a menu screen in a video game mod that never really got anywhere: as for what I *could* do, well there's always stuff I could add. Music is ever-changing. I'm sure Beethoven would still be fiddling around with his 9th Symphony were he not dead. As for the stagnancy of the piece, let me pose you a question: does war itself ever really lead anywhere?

I could have gone with the balls-out action score. Nothing says war hero like roaring brass, soaring strings, and an entire platoon of percussion. Sometimes, though, I feel there is a place for simplicity. As I stated in the review below yours, I found the original Gears of War advertisement to be really emotionally powerful: Gary Jules' soft, simplistic, and relatively stagnant cover of "Mad World" over the images of war and despair.

As for studying more theory? I think I'll pass on that -- five years of classical theory training (and a year of required jazz theory) was more than enough for me... if I'm required to study any more theory, I think I'll go crawl under a rock XD

Thank you for taking the time to write such a detailed review. You have mentioned many helpful things that I will bear in mind as I go forward with my compositions.

Thanks again,
- James

I could dance!

This is really nice!

The balance that you have is wonderful. The snare throughout the piece is at a superb level. A lot of people seem to overdo the snare, but you have it sitting at such a place that it enhances the texture without being distracting. The same with your use of marimba/mallet instrument.

The orchestration is really nice as well. I love how you double the piccolo and strings around :45 seconds in. On a different note, the subtle string patterns (like the grace note sounding thing at the beginning) make for a believable emulation of performers, even using virtual instruments.

Your use of dynamic contrast is also very thought out. It gives a certain organic feeling to the piece. You must have spent a fair deal of time on this piece. How long? What VSTs did you use?

I love this. The melodies are fun, and the instruments dance about one another in a fantastic manner. Wonderful! I can envision this in a professional film or video game.

Tomppaah responds:

Thank you very much! :)

"You must have spent a fair deal of time on this piece. How long?"
I sat for about 2 days straight on this one. :D I'm almost kinda sad that it's over, becouse it was so much fun working on this ;)

"What VSTs did you use?"
Everything you hear is EWQLSO :) I love that sample pack to bits!

Way too much 'verb!

Woah my friend, you have got way too much reverb on that piano sample! It makes the music sound like it's underwater.

That aside, I REALLY dig this. The licks that you use are awesome, and you've got a pretty colorful harmonic palette. Your playing is varied and articulate with great dynamic contrast. Just get rid of that stinkin' reverb! Well, that and I would have ended at 1:38 without the frilly thing at the end. It's too square. :p

Where did you learn to improv? I wish that I could play like that.

ajgreen24 responds:

You just made my day. I know this is one of my earlier pieces. im going to try my best to explain something that well somebody could write a book about. this cool lick you hear is something that has actually been lost to me. it was time when i didn't know much about music really, little knowledge and little rules. i played what i thought music should sound like after listening to oh so few songs. i was a musical idiot with the ulitimate creativity. ok so the reverb thing. ill agree that this was a little overboard on the reverb, however at the time i was trying to find a big concert hall feel but a clear and bright piano sound. something like your song called lullaby. this is incredably debatable. harmonics... interesting my music is made of harmony not really much melody but then agian classical is really non-meoldyish. i cant really say yeah ill do this or that for one thing i have no idea how to play this song it would take me a month to figure it out. the most intresting part. where did i learn to play improv and the answer is simply i didn't. i have self taught my self, basically everything with some help like somebody telling me - hay your playing in a minor. me - i didnt know that. ive been evidently playing since 5 however. the pace has picked up my freshman year of high school and has been going on for like the last 5 years. its really been intresting. if you like my work you can check it out at http://www.myspace.com/coldpiano . its very diverse from classical to like synth pop. if you dont like a lot of reverb you will hate piano doodle 3 with a passion. but it is like 12 minutes of pure i think awsome ... just listen to it. i know Im the king of long worded replies, but Keep playing my piano friend. thanks for the review.

Ending a bit weak, well done otherwise

My only gripe is with the ending. I felt that it would sound much stronger with a perfect authentic cadence (I assume you know some music theory, but I could be wrong). As it stands, the end sounds a bit weak and unsatisfying to what built up to it. Great job though. I enjoyed the loveliness.

Bezo responds:

Music theory is my bitch. It's a hymn. It has to end on the plagal cadence. Geez. ;)

Cool!

You've got some great stuff going on here! Your orchestration leads to an epic sort of sound, especially with the choir toward the beginning, ostinato bass lines, and brass. I liked the change of pace when the drum set came in.

My constructive criticism:
You have a piece of music that is over nine minutes here. In the age of television and infinite 30 second commercials though, the average listener's attention span is going to be far below that. In order to not lose people's attentions, an important principle should be kept in mind- the longer a piece of music is, the more structured it needs to be in order to make logical sense and keep the attention of the listener. Musical form is a study in and of istelf, but this can mean developing a theme and bringing it back every so often to provide your audience with something familiar which to grab hold of. It also means creating variety- a lot of the texture in this is very similar throughout. Try using a bit of counterpoint, changing these range that the melody is being played in, etc.

My other constructive criticism would be to pay more attention to phrasing. You have logical notes and rhythms here, but you need to make it musical in order to really touch a person emotionally. Have you instruments crescendo up to the top of a phrase and decrescendo back down. Use some tempo changes to keep the music from being too rigid. Tweak velocities to make the instruments sound more human and realistic. All of these little details take a long time, but they add a heck of a lot in making an amazing result. They are what make a piece go beyond 'cool' and into 'emotionally powerful.'

I really dig what you have going here and hope that you keep creating music. Keep it up!

5/5 and 9/10
Trevor Crookston (BlazingDragon)

OrphenFire responds:

Wow thanks for this extremely helpful insight. I'm working on phrasing. I'm learning how to make a computer generated "instrument" sound human, and it isn't easy lol. What you have to say is very helpful. The theme you hear beginning at about 1:17 is the main theme that I do come back to in several of the pieces after this. I use it again in Act 2 and Act 3, but those two compositions are not uploaded to NG as of yet... ;)

Trevor Crookston @BlazingDragon

Male

United States

Joined on 2/4/06

Level:
6
Exp Points:
305 / 400
Exp Rank:
> 100,000
Vote Power:
4.60 votes
Audio Scouts
2
Rank:
Civilian
Global Rank:
> 100,000
Blams:
0
Saves:
6
B/P Bonus:
0%
Whistle:
Normal
Trophies:
7
Medals:
38